Do you legally have to return a promise ring?

If a promise is broken, it is proper to return the promise ring just as a couple would return an engagement ring in the case of a broken engagement. If neither individual wants to keep the ring it could be sold and the money split.

Should I keep the ring my ex gave me?

If you’re wondering if you should return that expensive piece of jewelry to your ex, breathe easy. There’s no law saying you have to give these gifts back. Whether or not you return the piece of jewelry is completely up to you. In most cases, we don’t recommend giving it back.

Should I give back the jewelry my ex gave me?

So if you live here, you’re good. If giving the jewelry back to your ex gives you a sense of closure, or you feel guilty or uncomfortable keeping it, then by all means, return it. He might not accept it, but you could always try as a gesture of goodwill. And if not, it’s yours to do with as you see fit.

Does an engagement ring have to be returned if you break up?

Traditionally, an engagement ring is returned to the giver if the bride-to-be initiated the break-up or if it was mutual. If the giver ended the relationship, the wearer often keeps the ring or is given the option on what to do with the ring.

Is a promise ring considered a gift?

Unlike an engagement ring, promise rings are not given with the traditional elaborate planning of a formal proposal. They can be given on birthdays, Valentine’s Day, as a holiday gift, on a couple’s anniversary date, or even over a romantic dinner.

How long should you be in a relationship before you get a promise ring?

For these pre-engagement circumstances, you should give your partner the promise ring at least a year or more before you think you will actually propose. Giving your partner two commitment rings in less than a year is strange – superstitious people have even said this can jinx your relationship.

What should I do with my ex engagement ring?

Sell the whole ring or part of the ring for store credit and buy a piece of jewelry that you will love. Another option that some women choose is to return their engagement ring back to their ex. If an engagement is called off, the fiancé may have a legal right to the possession of the ring.

Can you take back a gift from an ex?

In general, once a gift is given (passes possession to you) it cannot legally be retrieved. There is an exception if there was a contract imputed or expressed for something in exchange for something, such as an engagement ring given on a promise to marry.

Who gets the ring after a broken engagement?

the giver
If the engagement is broken, the giver gets the ring back, regardless of the reasons for the split. This is similar to the no-fault divorce approach of family law.

Can a woman legally keep an engagement ring?

The ring is kept by the recipient, even if the marriage never occurs and no matter who broke the engagement. Once the marriage occurs, most states view the gifting of the ring as complete. In the event of a divorce, the recipient of the ring is entitled to keep the gift.

Which finger does a promise ring go on?

What finger do you wear a promise ring on? Promise rings can be worn on any finger. Popular options are the ring finger or the middle finger of the left hand or the middle or fourth finger on the right hand. Some people also wear a promise ring on a chain around their neck.

Can I get my engagement ring back after a divorce?

As a divorce lawyer, I am often asked whether it is possible to get the ring back. That is especially the case when the engagement ring was purchased with multiple commas! Unfortunately, the answer is likely no except in a few cases.

Should I give My Ex-Wife my engagement ring as a gift?

So, men — if you cheated during the engagement and she didn’t wed, the ring is hers. Conversely, the minority rule says that fault in the breakup should not be considered. Rather, the giving of the ring is viewed as bestowing upon the donee (i.e. your future wife) a conditional gift. The condition is marriage.

What happens to the ring when you marry the donee?

Rather, the giving of the ring is viewed as bestowing upon the donee (i.e. your future wife) a conditional gift. The condition is marriage. When that condition fails, the donor is entitled to a return of the ring (even in cases of infidelity).

Who is entitled to a ring after a breakup?

First, the majority rule states that fault determines entitlement to a ring. So, men — if you cheated during the engagement and she didn’t wed, the ring is hers. Conversely, the minority rule says that fault in the breakup should not be considered.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vOGS8GCWr2Y