Guidelines

Is Arthur Dayne better than Barristan selmy?

by Author

Is Arthur Dayne better than Barristan selmy?

GRRM has stated that a duel between Ser Arthur Dayne and Ser Barristan Selmy would end in a draw provided Dayne used a normal sword instead of Dawn. Otherwise, Dayne would win. This goes to prove that even without dawn , Dayne is an extremely deadly and prodigious swordsman.

Is rhaegar better than Arthur Dayne?

Ser Arthur Dayne was almost undoubtably a better swordsman than Rhaegar – he was capable, but Dayne was excellent. The reason Ser Arthur wasn’t at the Trident is because Rhaegar sent him, Lord Commander Hightower and Ser Whent to the Tower of Joy to protect Lyanna Stark and her (then unborn) child.

READ:   How many joules does it take to launch a rocket?

Was Ser Barristan the best swordsman?

2 Barristan Selmy He must have really needed a good Kingsguard, since Barristan fought for Aerys in the rebellion, fought against Robert. But it’s pretty widely accepted that Barristan Selmy is one of the greatest swordsmen of his time.

Is Arthur Dayne better than Jaime Lannister?

Arthur Dayne would win, as he has been touted as the greatest swordsman of his time, and wields a Valyrian sword unlike Jaime. Unlike Jaime who could only hold his own against the Smiling Knight, Ser Arthur was able to actually defeat him.

Who are the best swordsman in Game of Thrones?

10 Strongest Swordsmen In Game of Thrones, Ranked By Strength

  • 8 Greatjon & Smalljon Umber.
  • 7 Ser Brienne Of Tarth.
  • 6 Ser Arthur Dayne.
  • 5 Tormund Giantsbane.
  • 4 Khal Drogo.
  • 3 Sandor ‘The Hound’ Clegane.
  • 2 Robert Baratheon.
  • 1 Gregor ‘The Mountain’ Clegane.

Who did Ned Stark say was the best swordsman?

Ned again finds himself dueling one-on-one with a much, much better swordsman, Ser Arthur Dayne.

READ:   Does Stannis beat the Boltons in the books?

How good is Barristan selmy?

He is noted as an extremely capable warrior, even in his old age, and has a reputation for honor and chivalry that is second to none. He served in the Kingsguard of Aerys II Targaryen, becoming a great friend of the Targaryen dynasty. Ser Barristan was made a member of the Kingsguard when he was 23 years old.

Who was the greatest swordsman in Westeros?

Barristan Selmy Arguably the greatest swordsman in Westeros, Barristan was a living legend. However, he only makes number eight on this list because as good as he was in his prime, he was relatively old during the start of the show.

Was Ser Arthur Dayne the greatest warrior in Westeros?

Ser Arthur Dayne was the greatest warrior in Westeros. George RR Martin said this. But, Ser Barristan Selmy was almost equal to him. Martin said the only advantage Ser Arthur Dayne has over Ser Barristan is his greatsword Dawn, which was forged from an asteroid.

READ:   Do expensive instruments sound better?

How would you compare Barristan the Bold to Arthur Dayne?

Arthur Dayne is like JRR Tolkien- The original, the master who everyone respects, immobilized in history as a great. Barristan the Bold is like GRR Martin- The respected grandfather who everyone knows and respects, not as immobilized as Arthur but more known in present.

Is Jaime Lannister better than Arthur Dayne?

Georgia R.R. Marthin has mentioned that Jaime Lannister is just as good as Arthur Dayne, but couldn’t win in fight with Dayne because of his sword, he didn’t really Arthur literally destroy Jaime. He just mentioned Arthur’s sword being a great advantage.

Who is more powerful Jaime or Barristan or Arthur?

Barristan, Jaime and Arthur are roughly equal if Jaime has both his hands, Barristan is in his prime and Arthur *doesn’t* use Dawn. Arthur is the most effective of all of them if he is using Dawn, the most “special” (magical) weapon in the books, so far at least.