Is Polybius a credible source about how democratic Roman Republic was?

Polybius is a more reliable source than other ancient historians because he is a primary source as oppose to other historians who were not primary sources.

What did Polybius say about the Roman Republic?

Polybius believed that Rome’s constitution was effective for two reasons. Firstly, the constitution adapted to suit human nature. Secondly, it prevented what he referred to as “anacyclosis,” a cyclical theory of political evolution and decay.

How democratic do you think the Roman Republic was?

The government of the Roman Republic was neither strictly a monarchy (rule by one) or a direct democracy (rule by all). It had democratic features but was essentially a “fundamentally undemocratic society dominated by a select caste of wealthy aristocrats” (Brown, 2016, para.

What is the main reason Polybius valued the study of history?

Polybius believed that he had a particular reason for adopting a comprehensive view of history, apart from his own predilection for such a view. He wrote: For clearly the value of history as a source of practical lessons is diminished if cause and effect are at the mercy of an incalculable and capricious power.

How did that make Rome more democratic?

How did Roman Republic become more democratic? Rome contributed to democracy by creating a government where the people ruled. … Rome had senators and tribunes elected by the people to represent their interests.

What three things did Polybius consider the main causes of Rome’s greatness?

Most influential was Book 6, which describes Roman political, military, and moral institutions, which he considered key to Rome’s success; it presented Rome as having a mixed constitution in which monarchical, aristocratic, and popular elements existed in stable equilibrium.

Why was the Roman Republic so democratic?

Put simply, the vast majority of the Roman population had limited ability to exercise the powers afforded to them by the constitution. They had little to no influence on legislation and could only select leaders from a very small aristocratic caste.

Which democratic ideal came from the Romans?

Which democratic ideal came from the Romans? Answer: Once free, the Romans established a republic, a government in which citizens elected representatives to rule on their behalf. A republic is quite different from a democracy, in which every citizen is expected to play an active role in governing the state.

What sources did Polybius use?

Polybius regarded oral sources as his most important, and the questioning of witnesses as the most vital part of a historian’s task; indeed, this is one reason why he chose to begin his main history at the year 220. Anything else would be “hearsay at one remove,” a safe foundation for neither judgments nor statements.

What is the best form of government according to Polybius?

The ideal of a mixed government was popularized by Polybius, who saw the Roman Republic as a manifestation of Aristotle’s theory (Millar, 2002). Monarchy was embodied by the consuls, the aristocracy by the Senate and democracy by the elections and great public gatherings of the assemblies.

How does Millar’s description compare to Polybius’ description in document a?

Corroboration: How does Millar’s description of the Roman government compared to Polybius’ description in Document A Millar’s description is more balanced as it adds to the description presented by Polubius but does provide the caveat that such description is only true in form and not in substance. Document C: Alan Ward 1. Sourcing: Who is Ward?

What powers did the Roman people have According to Millar?

Because in the roman political System, the power of the people underpinned the Political process Which means that the roman Republic already used Democracy as their Governmental system. 3. Close Reading: According to Millar, what powers did the Roman people have? How did that make Rome more democratic? the answer is roman powers 4.

Where did they land in the Roman Republic?

They landed in Virginia The Roman Republic: Final Conclusion After reading all three documents, to what extent do you think the Roman Republic was democratic? Make sure to use historical evidence to support your argument!

Who were the patricians in the Roman Republic?

In Roman society, the aristocrats were known as patricians.The most elevated positions in the administration were held by two diplomats, or pioneers, who governed the Roman Republic. A senate made out of patricians chose these consuls.