Is revenge justified in court?

Historically, revenge has not been viewed as a legitimate justification for punishment under American legal principles. However, in the past year, both the United States Supreme Court and the Department of Justice have signaled that revenge may well have a legitimate role in justifying the death penalty.

Can revenge killing be justified?

A homicide performed out of vengeance, or retribution for action in the past, or in pursuit of a “fleeing felon” (except under specific circumstances) would not be considered justifiable. In many states, given a case of self-defense, the defendant is expected to obey a duty to retreat if it is possible to do so.

Can you achieve justice through revenge?

Revenge would be when you possibly do something harmful to the other person, just so that you can seek your own personal revenge. So basically, revenge is done to satisfy the party who suffered the wrongdoing, while justice is done for the sake of putting a semblance of fairness to society.

Does revenge avenge for justice violate the rule?

Revenge is an act of vindictiveness; justice, of vindication. The intense effort to avenge oneself or others can easily become corrupting, morally reducing the avenger’s status to that of the perpetrator. Two wrongs do not make a right and (ethically speaking) never can.

Is revenge ever necessary?

But while the need for revenge can be understandable, experts say it is never healthy. Some people equate revenge with seeking justice, but the two are not the same. People who seek revenge are driven by anger and violence and have not thought about how channel their negative feelings into something positive.

Do you believe Montresor’s revenge was justified?

In “The Cask of Amontillado,” revenge is not justified. The narrator, Montresor, tells his listener that Fortunato had he had borne…

Is revenge a moral issue?

Revenge is never ethical, regardless if it is minor or less in severity than the perceived offense. Two wrongs do not make a right, and no one who wants revenge has a moral ground worth standing on.

Is revenge a fair form of justice?

Revenge is about retaliation; justice is about restoring balance. The motive of revenge has mostly to do with expressing rage, hatred, or spite. In and of itself, it’s not primarily about justice but about victims’ affirming their inborn (but non-legal) right to retaliate against some wrong done to them.

Is revenge justified article?

However, if the victim of the crime believes the system has brought proportionate punishment upon the criminal, then the individual has also been avenged. Since both the state and victim have achieved appropriate retribution, the act can be considered justified revenge.

Is revenge a Justified Action?

Also, other person get damaged, acording a book The Count of Monte Cristo, Dantes wanted to revenge Fernand but, his wife and son had damaged. Revenge is not a justified action. If you are suffering injustice from somebody else, the correct response is not to take out your psychological or physical torment on the person.

Is rerevenge justified?

Revenge is not a justified action. If you are suffering injustice from somebody else, the correct response is not to take out your psychological or physical torment on the person. The correct response would be to logically assert the matter and proceed to create a justified conclusion.

Should revenge be the punishment for crime?

The punishment depends on the situation and the form of punishment taken, but in most cases revenge is not Justified, and retribution or reparation are better options. If a person commits a crime, they should obviously be punished as with any Justice system. However, revenge should be avoided as an option.

Is retribution justified?

As the crimes get more serious, retribution as a form of punishment becomes very similar to revenge and this is the only time when revenge is Justified. For example, if a person murders someone else then with retribution, the person should pay the same fate in jail, or in some countries, as capital punishment.